[lacer]

laced it does lets say Hani rdm's Gabe you and Nopleez and none of you care is it still mass rdm is it a perma bann.

Putting aside the fact that Hani and Nopleez aren't staff, which was your original point, and that this is a completely unrealistic situation

It's still mass RDM, which is a perma, according to the rules. However, if Hani, after being banned, decided to appeal as you have, then that's a different topic entirely.