Yes, this shows proof of several individuals doing questionable things; do you know what I don't see? Evidence of ANY staff member reaching out to each individual to try and correct the problem before it reached this stage. This is an execution of commonly known players. Don't get me wrong, I don't particularity get along with all those accused but there should still be evidence that the individuals were counseled and they understood the situation.
Now, if there is evidence that all these individuals being punished had been given a sufficient number of warnings for their specific violations or whatever you so desire to call it; then I can understand this punishment. Yes, they're able to apply to be community unbanned on X date but after a display like this it's obvious that the point is to keep these people away permanently.
A point was made how some of these conversations happened outside of Dinks community
(meaning in other discords), people are free to speak their minds. So what if someone doesn't like Dink? or how he handles his server.
What you've now done is created a fear for other players that they can't speak negatively about Dink or the server. Honestly, there's plenty of bad things about the server. Why? It's run by humans and they make mistakes and have not only good personalities but piss poor personalities too.
Going ENTIRELY off what is presented here, I believe this situation was handled wrong.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying what each person has done is/was right.
What I'm saying is that this whole situation could've been prevented or handled on a lower level.
I hope you all have a good day/week/month I will now go back to being the dead.